几何尺寸与公差论坛------致力于产品几何量公差标准GD&T (GDT:ASME)|New GPS(ISO)研究/CAD设计/CAM加工/CMM测量 - 查看单个帖子

using acrow props as trench struts
i have a temporary works job where the design engineer has specified acrow props to be used as trench struts. i am used to these being used in a vertical position such as for supporting formwork or an opening but i am dubious about their capacity in a horizontal position.
has anyone had any experience with this?
find a job or post a job opening
the water authority that i used to work for used them for many years in trenching operations and they were satisfactory. i had a few problems in severe works (had 2 that completely buckled !) but generally they are quite good.
thanks
do you use the full rated capacity or reduce the a little for bending?
we just used them didn't worry about designing them, it was for timbering and some trench shielding and they were about 4' long. if your designing, i would reduce the rated capacity by maybe 5 to 7% due to the bending. other than that they are quite good for this application.
thanks, i automatically discounted them when i saw them but i may rethink that.
i have seen acrow jacks used to prop trench sheeting on a number of occasions with no problem. the trenches were usually pretty small.
used horizontally there would be an additional bending generated within the prop but i would expect this to be pretty small. the bending may induce secondary effects as the prop is not a single
thanks ussuri and civeng80,
i cannot find anything to say definately no but i cannot find any guidance on it either. at least i know it has been done elsewhere.
try
i would check with acrow. why not use trench jacks which are designed for this purpose?

2009-09-16, 05:53 PM	#1
huangyhg 超级版主注册日期: 04-03 帖子: 18592 精华: 36 现金: 249466 标准币资产: 1080358888 标准币	using acrow props as trench struts using acrow props as trench struts i have a temporary works job where the design engineer has specified acrow props to be used as trench struts. i am used to these being used in a vertical position such as for supporting formwork or an opening but i am dubious about their capacity in a horizontal position. has anyone had any experience with this? find a job or post a job opening the water authority that i used to work for used them for many years in trenching operations and they were satisfactory. i had a few problems in severe works (had 2 that completely buckled !) but generally they are quite good. thanks do you use the full rated capacity or reduce the a little for bending? we just used them didn't worry about designing them, it was for timbering and some trench shielding and they were about 4' long. if your designing, i would reduce the rated capacity by maybe 5 to 7% due to the bending. other than that they are quite good for this application. thanks, i automatically discounted them when i saw them but i may rethink that. i have seen acrow jacks used to prop trench sheeting on a number of occasions with no problem. the trenches were usually pretty small. used horizontally there would be an additional bending generated within the prop but i would expect this to be pretty small. the bending may induce secondary effects as the prop is not a single thanks ussuri and civeng80, i cannot find anything to say definately no but i cannot find any guidance on it either. at least i know it has been done elsewhere. try i would check with acrow. why not use trench jacks which are designed for this purpose? __________________ 借用达朗贝尔的名言：前进吧，你会得到信心! [url="http://www.dimcax.com"]几何尺寸与公差标准[/url]